What changed this quarter: From August through October 2026, 15 homes sold in Atherton, California — and 9 of them (60%) closed above their list price, with the median sale 8.0% over asking. Atherton ranked 10th of 23 Peninsula towns for how often a home sells over asking. The largest overbid, at 1 Manzanita Road, closed 37.0% over asking — $3,050,000 above its list price.
Search Homes
Atherton | Palo Alto | Pacific Heights
Each link opens a live search of current listings in that area on my website.
In Atherton, an overbid is not an occasional event. In the August–October 2026 quarter it was the majority outcome: 9 of the 15 Atherton homes that sold closed above their list price. Below are all nine of those sales, presented two ways — first ranked by percentage over asking, then ranked by dollars over asking — because the two rankings tell two different stories, and both matter when you are pricing, bidding, or advising on an Atherton property.
Atherton: The Biggest Overbids by Percentage
1 Manzanita Road led the quarter, a 4-bedroom house listed at $8,250,000 that sold for $11,300,000 — 37.0% over asking.
| # | Home | List | Sold | Over | % Over |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 Manzanita Rd — 4 bd · 4 ba · 2,880 sq ft | $8,250,000 | $11,300,000 | +$3,050,000 | +37.0% |
| 2 | 134 Hawthorne Dr — 4 bd · 3 ba · 2,110 sq ft · 40,099 sq ft lot · built 1950 | $7,988,000 | $10,500,000 | +$2,512,000 | +31.4% |
| 3 | 28 Holbrook Ln — 5 bd · 5 ba · 3,765 sq ft · 21,204 sq ft lot · built 1921 | $5,888,000 | $7,210,000 | +$1,322,000 | +22.5% |
| 4 | 269 Oak Grove Ave — 7 bd · 9 ba · 6,401 sq ft · 1-acre lot · built 1989 | $15,000,000 | $18,000,000 | +$3,000,000 | +20.0% |
| 5 | 265 Atherton Ave — 4 bd · 4 ba · 5,212 sq ft · 42,537 sq ft lot · built 2015 | $15,572,000 | $18,236,000 | +$2,664,000 | +17.1% |
| 6 | 198 Catalpa Dr — 4 bd · 5 ba · 4,625 sq ft · 1.02-acre lot · built 2011 | $13,800,000 | $15,736,000 | +$1,936,000 | +14.0% |
| 7 | 27 Valley Rd — 4 bd · 5 ba · 4,643 sq ft · 1.04-acre lot · built 1995 | $9,888,070 | $11,000,000 | +$1,111,930 | +11.2% |
| 8 | 98 Rebecca Ln — 5 bd · 5 ba · 3,950 sq ft · 39,204 sq ft lot · built 1963 | $7,500,000 | $8,100,000 | +$600,000 | +8.0% |
| 9 | 49 Atherton Ave — 5 bd · 6 ba · 6,490 sq ft · 40,511 sq ft lot · built 1999 | $14,800,000 | $15,800,000 | +$1,000,000 | +6.8% |
Read the percentage ranking carefully. The three largest percentage overbids — 1 Manzanita Road at +37.0%, 134 Hawthorne Drive at +31.4%, and 28 Holbrook Lane at +22.5% — were not the quarter’s highest-priced sales. They were homes listed between $5,888,000 and $8,250,000 where competition pushed the final price far beyond the asking figure. At the top of the market, 269 Oak Grove Avenue (+20.0%) and 265 Atherton Avenue (+17.1%) still closed well over asking, but the deepest percentage premiums appeared where the list price left the most room for buyers to compete.
What this means for my clients, as their fiduciary
A list price in Atherton is a starting position, not a prediction. When 60% of sales close over asking and the median sale is 8.0% over, a fiduciary’s job is to test every list price against the pattern of comparable overbids before treating it as value — for a buyer deciding how far to stretch, for a seller deciding where to set expectations, and for a trustee or executor who must be able to show that the price achieved, or the price paid, was tested against the real market and not simply accepted.
Atherton: The Biggest Overbids in Dollars
1 Manzanita Road also led in dollars: it sold for $11,300,000, which is $3,050,000 over its $8,250,000 list price.
| # | Home | List | Sold | Over | % Over |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 Manzanita Rd — 4 bd · 4 ba · 2,880 sq ft | $8,250,000 | $11,300,000 | +$3,050,000 | +37.0% |
| 2 | 269 Oak Grove Ave — 7 bd · 9 ba · 6,401 sq ft · 1-acre lot · built 1989 | $15,000,000 | $18,000,000 | +$3,000,000 | +20.0% |
| 3 | 265 Atherton Ave — 4 bd · 4 ba · 5,212 sq ft · 42,537 sq ft lot · built 2015 | $15,572,000 | $18,236,000 | +$2,664,000 | +17.1% |
| 4 | 134 Hawthorne Dr — 4 bd · 3 ba · 2,110 sq ft · 40,099 sq ft lot · built 1950 | $7,988,000 | $10,500,000 | +$2,512,000 | +31.4% |
| 5 | 198 Catalpa Dr — 4 bd · 5 ba · 4,625 sq ft · 1.02-acre lot · built 2011 | $13,800,000 | $15,736,000 | +$1,936,000 | +14.0% |
| 6 | 28 Holbrook Ln — 5 bd · 5 ba · 3,765 sq ft · 21,204 sq ft lot · built 1921 | $5,888,000 | $7,210,000 | +$1,322,000 | +22.5% |
| 7 | 27 Valley Rd — 4 bd · 5 ba · 4,643 sq ft · 1.04-acre lot · built 1995 | $9,888,070 | $11,000,000 | +$1,111,930 | +11.2% |
| 8 | 49 Atherton Ave — 5 bd · 6 ba · 6,490 sq ft · 40,511 sq ft lot · built 1999 | $14,800,000 | $15,800,000 | +$1,000,000 | +6.8% |
| 9 | 98 Rebecca Ln — 5 bd · 5 ba · 3,950 sq ft · 39,204 sq ft lot · built 1963 | $7,500,000 | $8,100,000 | +$600,000 | +8.0% |
The dollar ranking shows the scale of the premiums at Atherton price levels. Five of the nine overbids added more than $1,900,000 above list: 1 Manzanita Road (+$3,050,000), 269 Oak Grove Avenue (+$3,000,000), 265 Atherton Avenue (+$2,664,000), 134 Hawthorne Drive (+$2,512,000), and 198 Catalpa Drive (+$1,936,000). Even the smallest dollar overbid on this list, 98 Rebecca Lane at +$600,000, is a substantial sum by any other market’s standards. Every one of the nine sales added at least $600,000 over asking.
What this means for my clients, as their fiduciary
Dollar overbids of this size change the arithmetic of a transaction. For a seller, a pricing strategy that invites competition can be worth millions — but only if the property, its presentation, and its timing genuinely support that competition. For a buyer, a $2 million to $3 million premium over asking has to be underwritten by the property itself, not by the heat of the bidding. And for trustees, executors, and family fiduciaries, these figures are the record against which a sale will later be judged: documenting why a price was accepted, in a quarter when Atherton premiums ran from +$600,000 to +$3,050,000, is part of protecting the estate.
The Same Pressure at San Francisco’s Top End: A $34.95 Million Pacific Heights Listing
Atherton is not the only Bay Area market where the top end is moving. In Pacific Heights, San Francisco, a circa-1890s mansion on Broadway — the Gold Coast — has been listed for $34.95 million, making it one of the city’s priciest public listings. The sellers are sisters Kathryn Hope and Pamela Kringel, whose parents, business executive David Chamberlain and his wife Karin Chamberlain, purchased the house for $3.95 million in 1989. David and Karin died earlier this year; David was a former CEO of health-supplement maker Shaklee and of footwear companies Stride Rite and Genesco.
The house spans about 9,000 square feet with seven bedrooms across four floors, near the Presidio and the Golden Gate Bridge. It is, in Hope’s words, a “hide-and-seek kind of house” — a bookshelf in the foyer conceals a hidden door into the kitchen. The family did minimal work before moving in, relocated to Boston around 2000 for David’s work while keeping the San Francisco house, and returned in 2007. After returning, the Chamberlains completed a major renovation: opening up the kitchen to make a living and dining space with a walkout terrace, adding an elevator that connects all four floors, shoring up the foundation — having lived through San Francisco’s 1989 earthquake, they made the house, in Hope’s word, “impenetrable” — and adding a two-car garage, while preserving historic details such as the curved metal balusters her father was proud of.
The sisters are selling because Hope has her own home in San Francisco and Kringel now lives in South Dakota. Broadway is a prestigious street where Laurene Powell Jobs paid around $70 million for a mansion in 2024.
The market behind the list price: fourteen San Francisco homes have sold for $20 million or more this year, compared with eight last year. The Wall Street Journal’s coverage attributes the strength at this tier to the paucity of available homes driving prices, with the artificial-intelligence boom very real in the market.
What this means for my clients, as their fiduciary
This listing is, at its heart, an estate story — the same kind of transition I advise on. Parents bought in 1989 for $3.95 million, held the property across a move to Boston and back, renovated it substantially after 2007, and now, after their deaths earlier this year, their daughters are bringing it to market at $34.95 million, with one sister local and the other in South Dakota. Every element a fiduciary has to manage is in that arc: a long-held family asset, a documented history of capital investment, heirs in different states, and a pricing decision that has to be defensible to the whole family. Fourteen sales at $20 million or more this year, against eight last year, is the market evidence that supports an ambitious asking price — and it is exactly the kind of evidence that belongs in the file when an estate property is priced.
What These Numbers Mean for Your Property
For buyers
Budget for the market Atherton actually is, not the one the list prices suggest. With 9 of 15 sales over asking and a median sale 8.0% over asking in August–October 2026, an offer at list price was, more often than not, not a winning offer. The strongest percentage premiums — up to +37.0% at 1 Manzanita Road — appeared below the very top of the market, so competition is not confined to trophy properties. Go in knowing the comparable overbids for the specific property you are pursuing, and know your ceiling before the bidding starts.
For sellers
This quarter rewarded sellers whose pricing invited competition: every one of the nine overbid sales cleared asking by at least 6.8%, and the top five dollar premiums each exceeded $1,900,000 over list. But an overbid is an outcome of demand meeting the right list price — it is not a guarantee, and 6 of the 15 Atherton sales in the same quarter did not close over asking. Pricing, condition, and presentation still decide which side of that line a property lands on.
For trustees, executors and family fiduciaries
An estate sale in Atherton does not take place in a list-price market. In August–October 2026, the documented range of outcomes ran from sales at or below asking to a +37.0% premium at 1 Manzanita Road and a +$3,050,000 premium in dollars. A fiduciary pricing an estate property, or reviewing an offer, should be working from this full range — and should be able to show beneficiaries and counsel how the asking price and the accepted price were each tested against it. That documentation is what turns a good outcome into a defensible one.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many Atherton homes sold over asking from August through October 2026?
Nine of the 15 homes that sold in Atherton from August through October 2026 closed above their list price — 60% of all sales in the quarter.
What was the biggest overbid in Atherton in August–October 2026?
1 Manzanita Road, by both measures. Listed at $8,250,000, it sold for $11,300,000 — +$3,050,000, or +37.0% over asking.
What was the median overbid in Atherton?
The median sale in Atherton from August through October 2026 closed 8.0% over asking. Atherton ranked 10th of 23 Peninsula towns for how often a home sells over asking.
What is the $34.95 million Pacific Heights listing?
A circa-1890s mansion on Broadway in Pacific Heights, San Francisco — about 9,000 square feet, seven bedrooms, four floors — listed for $34.95 million by sisters Kathryn Hope and Pamela Kringel. Their parents, David and Karin Chamberlain, bought it for $3.95 million in 1989 and renovated it extensively after returning to San Francisco in 2007. Fourteen San Francisco homes have sold for $20 million or more this year, compared with eight last year.
Does an overbid mean the buyer overpaid?
Not necessarily. An overbid measures the sale price against the final list price, and list prices are set strategically. What it does mean is that the list price alone did not predict the outcome — which is why comparable overbid data, property by property, belongs in every pricing and bidding decision.
Sources and Methodology
Pacific Heights segment: Wall Street Journal, “A Circa-1890s Mansion on San Francisco’s Gold Coast Lists for $34.95 Million” (November 2026) — listing price, property, family and renovation history, and the count of San Francisco homes sold for $20 million or more this year (14) versus last year (8). All Pacific Heights figures are for San Francisco and are labelled as such, separately from the Atherton figures above.
Data: Atherton residential sales, August–October 2026, as reported in the HighNote Atherton overbid report (published November 9, 2026, updated November 12, 2026), sourced from MLS data. How it was measured: every residential sale that closed in Atherton from August through October 2026, as reported by the MLS. The overbid is the sale price measured against the final list price. All figures in this post are for Atherton only and are labelled as such; the Peninsula ranking (10th of 23 towns) is the only Peninsula-wide figure included. Listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Disclaimer: Data is taken from sources deemed reliable but is subject to errors and omissions. ©2020 All rights reserved
Contact Catherine Bassick
If you are weighing a purchase, a sale, or an estate property decision in Atherton, start with what your property — or the property you are pursuing — is actually worth in this market: Contact Catherine Bassick to request a home valuation.
Browse properties: Atherton | Palo Alto | Pacific Heights
Each link opens a live search of current listings in that area.







Leave a Reply